The currrent proposal by New York City Department of Transportation (DOT) is for a cable-stayed bridge with a single pylon reaching some 50m high, whereas the current bridge stands less than 10m above the water level.

Borough president Ruben Diaz Jr said that City Island is a special zoning district, which limits any structure from exceeding approximately 12m. "Given that the proposed cable stayed City Island bridge will rise nearly 165 feet, I believe those on the Island are entirely correct when they object to this proposed new span. I, therefore believe it is imperative that the DOT modify the bridge. To do otherwise will severely impact the historical character of City Island."